Retired Flavors

Reece's Egg
Striped chocolate and peanut butter filling with chocolate icing topped with Reece's Egg crumbles

Strawberry Rhubarb
Strawberry and Rhubarb filling with vanilla icing and zig zagged with pink white chocolate

Blackberry Lavender
Blackberry lavender filling topped with vanilla, blackberry, and lavender icing that's drizzled with white chocolate

Cookie Dough
Chocolate chip cookie dough filling with vanilla icing and topped with mini chocolate chips

PB&J
Peanut butter and grape jelly filling with vanilla icing topped with salty nut topping and purple drizzle

Apricot Crumble
Apricot filling with vanilla icing and brown sugar cinnamon streusel

Bailey's and Guinness
Guinness infused dark chocolate fudge filling with Bailey's icing topped with St. Patrick's Day sprinkles

Sweet Heat
Spicy pepper jelly filling with sweet vanilla icing and Valentine's Day sprinkles

PRIDE Pineapple Passion Fruit
Pineapple and passion fruit filling with vanilla icing topped with PRIDE sprinkles

Cookies and Cream
Creamy vanilla filling with crumbles of Oreo cookies swirled throughout and sprinkled on top of vanilla icing

Strawberry Sunshine
Strawberry filling with bright and sunny sprinkles topped with of
strawberry icing

Cookie Butter
Cookie butter filling with Biscoff crumble topping

Cherry Pie
Michigan Cherry filling with vanilla icing and patriotic sprinkles

Blueberry Lemon
Blueberry filling with a lemon glaze and sprinkles

Chocolate Peanut Butter
Striped chocolate and peanut butter filling with chocolate icing zig zagged with peanut butter and topped with Reece's Pieces

Fig, Orange, & Honey
Fig and orange spread with a swirl of honey icing

Sufganiyot Strawberry
Sufganiyot is inspired by the jelly doughnuts of Hanukkah. Strawberry filled with vanilla powered sugar icing and festive sprinkles!

Orange Creamsicle
Orange Marmalade filling with creamy vanilla icing and topped with bright orange sprinkles

Pecan Pie
Chopped pecan pie filing topped with maple syrup icing

Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin pie filling with pumpkin butter icing zig zagged with vanilla cream cheese icing

Hott Cocoa
Chocolate filling with vanilla icing topped with milk chocolate nibs and crushed candy cane

Sparkling Pear
Pouched Bartlett pear filling with champagne flavored icing topped with silver and gold glitter sprinkles

Blueberry Crunch
Blueberry filling paired with vanilla icing topped with honey toffee milk chocolate covered cracker crumbles

Wild Berry
Rich and fruity black raspberries, strawberries, blackberries, red raspberry blend of filling with throw back vanilla icing

Cosmic Brownie
Brownie batter chocolate filling with milk chocolate icing and the classic Cosmic Brownie colored chocolate chips

Lemon Cookie
Lemon curd filling with vanilla icing and lemon cookie crumble topping

Lime Margarita
Lime curd filling topped with lime icing, salt, and lime garnish

S'more
Chocolate and marshmallow filling topped with chocolate icing and graham crackers

Nutella
Chocolate with a hint of roasted hazelnut spread topped with vanilla icing, Nutella zig zags, and rainbow sprinkles

Peachy Keen
Peach jam filling with vanilla icing and topped with a Peach O Candy Ring

Banana Cream Pie
Banana pudding with marshmallow fluff filling topped with yellow vanilla icing and graham cracker crumbles

Mango Peach
Juicy Mango and Peach filling with vanilla icing and sprinkles

Pina Colada
Pineapple filling with vanilla icing and toasted coconut topping

Blackberry Vanilla
Blackberry filling with vanilla icing and white sparkle sprinkles

Nutella Joy
Chocolate with a hint of roasted hazelnut spread topped with chocolate icing and toasted coconut

Holiday Jam
Cranberries, raspberries, pears, oranges, and holiday spices filling topped with vanilla icing and festive sprinkles

Mocha Latte
A rich espresso and dark chocolate filling with creamy vanilla icing topped with espresso powder and a chocolate covered espresso bean

Fruity Fall
Fig, Raspberry, Orange, and Ginger filling topped with vanilla icing fall festive sprinkles

Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Strawberry filling paired with chocolate icing topped with a dried strawberry heart

Apple Pie (aka Apple Chris)
Homemade chunky apple sauce with vanilla icing and fall sprinkles

Pumpkin Roll
Pumpkin pie and cinnamon bun spread filling with vanilla icing and Cinnamon Toast Crunch topping

Elaina's Winter Nutella
Chocolate with a hint of roasted hazelnut spread topped with blue vanilla icing, and winter sprinkles

Raspberry Delight
Raspberry jam filling with raspberry and vanilla icing topped with sprinkles